返回首页| 繁體中文| 设为首页| 加入收藏
您所在的位置: 首页 >> 港澳新闻

党报专访香港法律专家:法官重判打人警察损害法治

2017/2/21    作者:

【香港新闻日报-记者许天平】2014年在“占中”中负责清场的7名香港警察,因涉嫌殴打袭警人士,近日被判入狱两年。这一判决震惊香港。至此,“占中”者普遍获轻判或逍遥法外,而辛苦执勤、承受巨大压力的警察却因一时失误遭重判。这样的判决是否合理,将对香港造成什么影响?

“保卫香港运动”成员近日在香港警察总部向警察递交感谢卡。

 

香港新闻日报-记者许天平】2014年在“占中”中负责清场的7名香港警察,因涉嫌殴打袭警人士,近日被判入狱两年。这一判决震惊香港。至此,“占中”者普遍获轻判或逍遥法外,而辛苦执勤、承受巨大压力的警察却因一时失误遭重判。这样的判决是否合理,将对香港造成什么影响?

 

社会普遍不满

 

“我个人对这个判决感到非常意外”,香港城市大学法律学院副院长顾敏康教授接受本报记者专访时表示。他说,一般而言,司法独立意味着法官判决案件不需要各方满意。但是,当一个判决令社会大众普遍感觉不满意时,很难说这个判决是公正的。

顾敏康说,毫无疑问,警察在执法时殴打疑犯是不可以的,也可能因此构成犯罪,但对7名警察一律判处两年监禁显然是过重了。法官根本没有考虑这7名警察当时面对的是穷凶极恶的疑犯,他们被围攻、被淋尿液、被辱骂,殴打疑犯是在极其愤怒下的激情冲动行为。他们也因为自己的冲动失去职位和有关福利,已经受到惩罚。在这种情况下,罪成而判缓刑是比较合理的。

诉讼期间,法庭收到上千封来自市民的求情信,为警察中的首被告求情。警察被定罪后,有法庭外民众当场痛哭失声,批评“判太重”“警察难做”。2月20日,不少香港市民和民间团体上街声援警察,并为失去俸禄的他们募捐生活费。

 

法官立场偏颇

 

香港适用的是英美法系的普通法(判例法),法官拥有较大的自由裁量权。对此,顾敏康认为,此案中法官的立场的确引起了公众的质疑,因为人们看到那些反政府人士虽然因为冲击政府或袭警被判罪成,但往往是“高高提起、轻轻放下”、所判处的刑罚往往是社会服务令;相反,为维护香港法治作出贡献的警察却因为冲动殴打行为需要被监禁两年。“如果这样都可以,那么香港的法治就令人十分担忧了。”

判决此案的法官杜大卫是英国人,而香港法律系统中不仅有大量外国籍法官,且更多人是港英政府培养出来的。顾敏康说,从制度上讲,《基本法》允许保留这种状况。但是,这种制度显然存在商榷的地方,那就是立场问题可能影响他们对案件的判断。

他举例说,法官在轻判冲击政府广场的学生领袖黄之锋、罗冠聪和周永康时,认为此案与其他刑事案件不同,他们犯罪是因为出于良好的动机,即真心因自己政治理念或对社会现状的关心而“表达自己诉求”(冲击变成了表达诉求)。

 

法治严重受损

 

袭警的曾健超仅被判囚5周且获缓刑,7名警察成了整个“占中”事件中获罪最重的人。顾敏康认为,这个判决对香港法治的冲击巨大,因为“占中”搞手至今逍遥法外,维护法治的警察因为冲动行为被重判,令将警察妖魔化的反政府人士感觉理直气壮,令整个警队的士气严重被挫,政府依法施政将不可避免受到更大阻力,社会将变得越来越动荡。这令人担忧。

2014年香港“占中”期间,7名警察肩负守护公共秩序的工作,示威者曾健超刻意挑衅在先,站在天桥上向桥下10多名警员淋泼尿味液体并拒捕,眼见同僚受辱,7名警察在拘捕过程被指殴打曾健超。香港舆论普遍认为,7名警察对曾健超有辱人格的挑衅产生反应是人之常情,绝非恶意或无缘无故的袭击,也没有对曾健超造成严重伤害。因此,特区政府律政司将7名警察告上法庭,本来就是小题大做。

对此,律政司起诉警察也是依制度办事,但“占中”过去两年多,律政司却迟迟不起诉“占中”搞手,对香港法治有重大负面影响。


·热门评论
匿名网友 发表于:2018/5/21 13:28:11
IP:31.6.31.* 
我来评两句!我来评两句!cc20180521

valentino shoes outlet

nike air max

nike air max 1

pandora jewelry

michael kors handbags

coach factory outlet online

nike dunks

ray ban sunglasses

yeezy boost

pandora jewelry outlet

jordan shoes

mulberry bags

ralph lauren outlet

pandora jewelry official site

cheap mlb jerseys

coach outlet

louis vuitton

pandora charms

cheap jordans

kate spade outlet

nike zoom

bally handbags

louis vuitton outlet online

christian louboutin outlet

michael kors outlet

cheap mlb jerseys china

coach outlet

nike outlet online

nike outlet

abercrombie

coach factory outlet

adidas superstar

air more uptempo

supreme clothing

nike store

birkenstock outlet

cheap nfl jerseys

underarmour shoes

coach outlet

michael kors handbags

oakley sunglasses

puma rihanna shoes

reebok shoes

jordan shoes

fitflops sale clearance

mcm handbags

prana clothing

christian louboutin outlet

the frye company shoes

christian louboutin shoes

adidas yeezy

timberland boots

mulberry handbags

hermes outlet

moncler coats

uggs

fitflops

canada goose outlet

givenchy handbags

air jordan shoes

adidas stan smith

harden vol 1

supreme clothing

polo outlet

ugg outlet

vans shoes

canada goose outlet

dansko shoes

kobe bryant shoes

louis vuitton outlet

rolex watches

moncler jackets

kate spade outlet

nike air max axis

cheap oakley sunglasses

burberry outlet

coach outlet

ralph lauren outlet

pandora charms sale

pg 2

ray ban sunglasses

coach outlet

air jordan shoes

pandora charms

kate spade outlet store

kenneth cole shoes

coach outlet store

ugg boots

coach canada

hermes handbags

columbia shoes

danner boots

coach factory outlet

teva sandals

givenchy handbags

nike tessen

reef sandals

caterpillar boots

polo ralph lauren outlet online

coach outlet store

moncler outlet

pandora jewelry outlet

nike zoom

salvatore ferragamo shoes

ralph lauren uk

adidas yeezy

air max 97

mikimoto pearls

coach outlet

gucci handbags

michael kors outlet clearance

vasque boots

mcm outlet

fred perry

coach factory outlet

florsheim shoes

vasque shoes

mont blanc pens

salvatore ferragamo shoes

nike outlet

vans store

adidas shoes

ralph lauren uk

birkenstock sandals

polo ralph lauren outlet

adidas yeezy

longchamp outlet

louboutin shoes

uggs outlet

arcteryx boots

tory burch outlet

coach outlet

oakley sunglasses

columbia sportswear

timberland boots

adidas yeezy boost

manolo blahnik shoes

kate spade outlet store

canada goose jackets

ray ban sunglasses

polo ralph lauren outlet

asics outlet

ralph lauren sale clearance

nike air max zero

coach outlet

adidas yeezy

lowa boots

nike outlet

moncler outlet

coach factorty outlet

kate spade outlet

valentino shoes

prada outlet

pandora charms

nike outlet store

coach outlet

ultra boost

timberland boots

canada goose sale

supreme new york

ralph lauren

yeezy boost

air max 2018

fitflops sale

nike air max 95

coach factory outlet

yeezy boost 350

adidas shoes

cheap oakley sunglasses

lacoste polo shirts

adidas originals

ecco outlet

birkenstock sandals

oakley sunglasses

kate spade handbags

adidas yeezy boost

nike outlet

tods outlet

fred perry polo

canada goose jackets

michael kors outlet

tory burch outlet

pandora charms

abercrombie and fitch

kate spade

air max 2017

ray ban sunglasses

converse outlet store

keen shoes

garmont boots

moncler outlet

wolverine boots

toms outlet

coach outlet

birkenstock sandals

tiffany and co

nike shoes

ralph lauren outlet

pandora outlet

nike react shoes

moncler jackets

salomon shoes

coach factorty outlet

moncler outlet

jordan retro 11

michael kors outlet

gap polo shirts

adidas outlet

fitflops sale clearance

canada goose outlet

nike epic react flyknit

michael kors

tiffany outlet

jordan shoes

nike free run

nike cortez

pandora jewelry

coach outlet canada

philipp plein outlet

louis vuitton handbags

johnston and murphy outlet

nike air foamposite

oakley sunglasses outlet

dooney and bourke handbags

pandora charms

cheap nfl jerseys

canada goose jackets uk

moncler

swarovski outlet

michael kors outlet

coach outlet store online clearances

michael kors outlet

nba jerseys

ralph lauren

coach factory outlet

unomagli shoes

kate spade handbags

adidas superstar

ugg outlet

michael kors outlet

allen edmonds shoes

discount oakley sunglasses

salvatore ferragamo shoes

michael kors outlet

nike air max 87

coach factory outlet

jimmy choo

ralph lauren outlet

red bottoms shoes

nike huarache

pandora jewelry

dolce and gabbana handbags

coach outlet

nmd adidas

hermes handbags

naot sandals

jordan shoes

red bottoms

keen sandals

canada goose uk

coach outlet store online

chch handbags

kyrie 4 shoes

air jordans

ugg outlet

vionic sandals

converse shoes

jimmy choo outlet

louis vuitton outlet online

canada goose sale

michael kors outlet clearance

coach factory outlet

fendi handbags

ugg outlet

canada goose sale

coach factorty outlet

adidas yeezy boost

coach outlet store

pandora outlet

red wing shoes

michael kors outlet canada

tory burch outlet online

canada goose jackets

coach outlet

michael kors outlet online

pandora charms

coach outlet

cheap mlb jerseys

kate spade

tory burch outlet store

pandora outlet

nike cortez

cole haan shoes

canada goose outlet

polo outlet store

canada goose jackets

nike air max shoes

van cleef and arpels jewelry

coach outlet online

canada goose jackets

ralph lauren sale clearance

red wing outlet

toms outlet

louis vuitton outlet store

yeezy boost

cheap ray bans

louboutin shoes

canada goose outlet

longchamp outlet online

timberland outlet

mbt

converse all star

oakley sunglasses

coach outlet store

lebron james shoes

michael kors outlet clearance

north face outlet

alden shoes

salomon shoes

canada goose outlet

uggs canada

jordans

adidas

coach outlet

hermes birkin

air jordans

north face jackets

burberry outlet

nike air max

dr martens boots

coach outlet

birkenstock outlet

burberry outlet store

yeezy boost

chopard watches

fitflops sale

michael kors outlet clearance

adidas shoes

ray ban sunglasses discount

yeezy boost

cheap oakley sunglasses

canada goose uk

dior handbags

birkenstock shoes

uggs

nike shoes

michael kors outlet

kobe shoes

coach outlet

birkenstock

prada handbags

nike air force 1

ugg australia

coach outlet

nike huarache

nfl jerseys wholesale

ray ban sunglasses discount

puma shoes

berluti shoes

dr martens

pandora jewelry

kate spade outlet

pandora jewelry

michael kors outlet

moncler outlet

swarovski crystal

nike air max 270

ralph lauren outlet online

timberland outlet

teva shoes

adidas shoes

michael kors outlet canada

tory burch outlet

pandora

adidas shoes

fitflops

adidas outlet

ralph lauren sale

polo ralph lauren outlet

adidas shoes

pandora jewelry

canada goose outlet

oakey sunglasses

givenchy outlet

pandora outlet

cartier outlet

longchamp handbags

canada goose jackets

tiffany and co

rolex watches

christian louboutin

asolo boots

mbt shoes

red bottom shoes

pandora charms uk

gucci handbags outlet

air max 90

uggs

jimmy choo outlet

nike free 4.0

coach factory outlet

philipp plein shirt

ecco shoes

new balance shoes

pandora jewelry

coach outlet store

air max 97

polo ralph lauren outlet online

mont blanc

michael kors outlet

pandora jewelry

mbt shoes

ecco shoes

adidas nmd shoes

coach factory outlet

pandora charms

coach outlet

ecco shoes for men

canada goose outlet

asics shoes

ugg boots on sale

michael kors outlet online

coach outlet online

coach factory outlet

adidas nmd

nike shoes

canada goose outlet

pandora charms sale clearance

moncler jackets

coach factory outlet

polo ralph lauren

ferragamo shoes

michael kors outlet online

pandora jewelry

north face jackets

harry winston jewelry

louis vuitton outlet

ysl handbags

pandora jewelry official site

hermens bags

fitflops

cheap jordans

coach factory outlet online

michael kors outlet

ralph lauren

nike air max outlet

moncler outlet

cheap jordans

cheap jordan shoes

armani exchange outlet

ralph lauren sale clearance

adidas nmd

toms shoes

pandora charms sale clearance

birkenstock sandals

nike outlet online

cheap jordans for sale

adidas campus

moncler jackets

salewa shoes

ralph lauren outlet

skechers shoes

mlb jerseys

hermes bags

cheap nike air max

adidas yeezy

supra shoes

mulberry outlet

cheap jordans

coach factory outlet

air max 2018

nike air max

ferragamo outlet

michael kors outlet online

polo outlet

christian louboutin outlet

canada goose outlet

michael kors outlet

coach factorty outlet

pandora charms sale clearance

gucci outlet

uggs outlet

canada goose outlet

ugg outlet

cheap uggs

pandora store

ugg boots

coach outlet store

new balance outlet

kate spade bags

nike shoes for men

nike basketball shoes

fitflops sale clearance

jordan shoes

cheap nba jerseys

canada goose

fitflops

kate spade outlet

cheap jordans

ralph lauren outlet

louboutin shoes

ralph lauren outlet

michael kors

timberland outlet

cheap jordans free shipping

pandora jewelry

coach outlet

michael kors outlet

moncler jackets outlet

cheap ray ban sunglasses

supra shoes

replica watches

birkenstock shoes

air max 2019

coach outlet

salvatore ferragamo

oakley sunglasses

mammut boots

yeezy 350 boost

ysl outlet

nike shoes

valentino shoes

michael kors outlet clearance

pandora charms

supreme clothing

michael kors outlet canada

birkenstocks

coach outlet

salvatore ferragamo

moncler jackets

burberry outlet

coach outlet

louis vuitton

coach outlet online

jordan shoes

merrell shoes

kate spade outlet store

hermes handbags

jordans

oakley sunglasses

michael kors factory outlet

timberland boots outlet

michael kors outlet

nike shoes

fitflops

john lobb boot maker shoes

michael kors outlet

kate spade

polo ralph lauren outlet online

nike air presto

longchamp outlet

canada goose

dr martens outlet

kate spade handbag

mulberry uk

cole haan outlet

ugg boots

coach outlet store

coach outlet

adidas nmd

nike air more money

ralph lauren outlet

saint laurent outlet

kevin durant shoes

coach factory outlet

christian louboutin

versace handbags

ecco shoes

saint laurent handbags

adidas outlet

coach outlet

nike shox

ugg boots on sale

jordan retro

cc20180521

[举报]  [引用
匿名网友 发表于:2017/3/2 16:05:04
IP:211.174.125.* 

ray-ban sunglasses

burberry outlet online

ray ban eyeglasses

kate spade black friday

burberry online

oakley outlet

michael kors uk

pandora rings

michael kors outlet

salomon hiking shoes

mlb shop

veronique billat

sunglasses sm

Basketball shoes

michael kors outlet

prada bags

abercrombie outlet

Abercrombie Fitch

abercrombie and fitch

coach outlet online

adidas australia

coach sunglasses

pandora jewelry

Jordan Retro Shoes

coach outlet

michael kors outlet online

kate spade outlet

burberry scarf

michael kors uk

coach purse

pandora charms sale

ray-ban sunglasses

hermes bag

Hugo Boss Store

burberry us

burberry outlet

pandora princess ring

prada outlet

michael kors bags

michael kors purses outlet

louboutin shoes

michael kors outlet

michael kors outlet bags

coach outlet

pandora.com

nfl shop

michael kors handbags

prada outlet

abercrombie and fitch

Hyperdunk 2016

hockey jerseys

michael kors canada

beats studio

ralph lauren australia

official prada site

kate spade

moncler down jackets

shoes online sale

kate spade outlet online

ups tracking

Oakley Holbrook

ray ban polarized

prada handbags

pandora rings

michael kors outlet

chanel australia

clk benz

Michael Kors Outlet

ugg boots

Coach Outlet

Ralph Lauren Polo

coach bags

michael kors tote

pandora uk

abercrombie and fitch

ugg australia

rayban aviator

polo outlet

michael kors outlet

snow boots

moncler us

pandora australia

canada goose jacket

burberry outlet

prada official site

burberry outlet online

coach outlet online

Hugo Boss Outlet

shoes online

michael kors purses on sale

Ralph Lauren

michael kors outlet

baseball jerseys

coach australia

tiffany co

michael kors outlet

prada factory outlet online

pandora rings

Nike Jordans

coach usa

burberry purse

burberry outlet

nike shoes

prada factory outlet online

football jerseys

Mizuno Shop

Chanel Outlet

piumini moncler replica

coach outlet

michael kors outlet online

pandora charms

michael kors outlet

huaraches shoes

air jordan retro

nike com

mlb shop

coach bags

coach outlet

mk handbags

cheap coach purse

nike jordan shoes

air jordan shoes

louis vuitton outlet

moncler jacket

michael kors outlet

Prada Factory Outlet

kate spade canada

canada goose jacket

pandora australia

nike shox

coach shoes

basketball jerseys

authentic prada handbags outlet

kate spade outlet

prada glasses

shoes sale

football jerseys

Yeezy 350

michael kors bags

michael kors outlet

burberry

coach outlet

beats by dre

coach outlet online

authentic prada outlet online

michael kors outlet

kate spade outlet

pandora necklaces

top sunglasses

pandora necklace charms

prada outlet online

oakley sunglasses

pandora rings

prada outlet online

coach outlet

abercrombie us

michael kors outlet

Jordan Retro

oakley frogskins sunglasses

coach factory outlet

kate spade outlet

asics shoes

prada sale

coach outlet

coach sunglasses for women

mk outlet

brand sunglasses

major league baseball

pandora bracelets

Coach outlet online

polo online

michael kors australia

nike free run

michael kors black friday

Mizuno Wave

louis vuitton outlet

prada outlet

prada factory outlet

michael kors tote

michael kors outlet

huaraches

michael kors outlet

michael kors outlet

baseball jerseys

burberry australia

pandora australia

burberry outlet

ray ban glasses

coach outlet store

paul smith

Kate Spade Australia

flash sunglasses

coach outlet online

kate spade bags

kate spade outlet

Mizuno Running Shoes

moncler outlet

nike outlet

baseball jerseys

pandora bracelet

michael kors factory outlet

nike huarache

longchamp outlet

yeezy boost 350

pandora bracelet

chanel

kate spade black friday

nike jordan

burberry outlet canada

ray ban aviator

ugg slippers

asics Australia

nike australia

jordan retro shoes

ray ban outlet

Nike Air Jordan

coach diaper bag

burberry scarfs

Prada Outlet

burberry outlet

china wholesale

prada outlet

coach factory outlet online

burberry scarf

pandora charms black friday

coach handbags

ugg australia

ray ban clubmaster

michael kors

michael kors wallet

prada sunglasses

pandora bracelet

Nike Hyperdunk Shoes

yeezy boost 350

salomon shoes

prada outlet

pandora rings

prada outlet online

coach carter

coach factory outlet

coach outlet

coach outlet

Pandora bracelet

yeezy boost 350

prada bags on sale

pandora charms

coach australia

Kevin Durant Shoes

burberry outlet canada

pandora charms

Longchamp Outlet

prada outlet prices

michael kors bags outlet

mens sunglasses

kate spade

abercrombie outlet

nike jordan shoes

kate spade outlet

oakley sunglasses

moncler clothing

mcm factory outlet

moncler sale

nike air huarache

tiffany co

jordan shoes

burberry canada

pandora necklace

Burberry outlet online

jimmy choo australia

coach outlet

Coach Outlet Online

michael kors outlet online

wholesale

burberry canada

cheap basketball shoes

huarache nike

polo outlet online

michael kors outlet

Michael Kors Outlet

prada bag

ray ban sunglasses

mk bags

Nike Air Jordan

ray ban sunglasses

michael kors handbags outlet

Mizuno Shoes

louis vuitton uk

ralph lauren

louis vuitton outlet

Nike Air Max

michael kors totes

pandora rings

prada bags

nike shoes australia

coach outlet

Coach Outlet Store

abercrombie outlet us

prada factory outlet online

michael kors

timberland boots

CHanel Factory Outlet

coach purses

oakley australia

nike australia

michael kors outlet

michael kors us

michael kors

bercrombie Nederland

coach factory outlet

kate spade outlet online

prada bags outlet

longchamp outlet

véronique Billat

prada outlet online

Hermes Outlet

oakley frogskins

coach australia

Coach Sunglasses Outlet

kate spade bags

burberry outlet

yeezy boost 350 shoes

moncler uk

authentic prada outlet online

Yeezy Boost 350

prada outlet online

michael kors purses

kate spade

prada purses

asics shoes Australia

coach bag

prada outlet online

Chanel bags Outlet

mlb.com

chanel bag

nike lebron james

pandora rings

Ray Ban Outlet

ray ban online

Cheap Ray Ban

michael kors outlet

cheap ray ban sunglasses

michael kors

canada goose outlet

coach factory

moncler coats

moncler jacket

timberland uk

ray ban new wayfarer

ray ban sunglasses

louis vuitton outlet

nike air max

michael kors outlet

nike shoes

pandora charms sale online

Oakley Outlet

michael kors purses

michael kors outlet

ray ban sunglasses

coach

kate spade bags outlet

Jordan retro

coach factory outlet

beats headphones

Nike Free

abercrombie outlet

michael kors outlet

abercrombie paris

mcm outlet online

burberry online

pandora uk

landinggear

abercrombie us

pandora ring

pandora australia

paul smith uk

prada bags

Adidas Yeezy Boost 350

Mizuno Shop Japan

abercrombie & fitch

pandora rings jewelry

prada online

louis vuitton australia

nike store

prada handbags

canada goose sale

moncler outlet

canada goose sale online

coach outlet

MIZUNO Shop US

nike basketball shoes

official michael kors

Pandora Charm

coach handbags

prada us

coach online

nike huarache shoes

pandora charms

pandora jewelry

michael kors handbags

pandora charms sale

moncler jacket

abercrombie fitch

Oakley Holbrook sunglasses

michael kors outlet

pandora jewelry

burberry australia

sunglasses hut

Free Run

cheap moncler jacket

louis vuitton factory outlet

ray-ban sunglasses

sunglasses outlet

paul smith sale

abercrombie outlet

michael kors online

prada outlet online

air jordan shoes

pandora charms sale clearance

adidas shoes

nike jordan shoes

michael kors bags

ugg uk

moncler jacket mens

moncler mens jackets

KD 8 shoes

Michael Kors Canada

basketball jerseys

lebron james shoes

nfl jerseys

michael kors outlet

oakley sunglasses

michael kors italy

pandora charms uk

coach outlet

landing gear

pandora charms

Nike Jordan Shoes

mcm outlet

pandora charms

nike id

landing gears

ate spade handbags

ray ban prescription sunglasses

michael kors jet set tote

michael kors outlet

Nike Hyperdunk 2015

nike outlet

Canada Goose Outlet

kate spade handbags

nike lebron shoes

Hugo Boss Online

prada outlet

prada outlet online

china factory sale

michael kors outlet

pandora rings

adidas yeezy boost 350

pandora rings sale

prada handbags

michael kors handbags

ray ban outlet

ray ban prescription glasses

abercrombie outlet

sunglasses hut

Nike KD 8

nike shox shoes

coach outlet

Prada bags

official prada site

mlb store

ray ban wayfarer

coach outlet

Billat

adidas australia

moncler outlet

burberry scarf

jlgg3.2
[举报]  [引用
验证码:
Failure
Failure